- A new analysis determined that highly engineered consumables are potentially just as habit-forming as tobacco products.
- The study authors observed that UPFs are formulated to heighten pleasure and speed up the absorption of reinforcing ingredients.
- The “addictive” quality of these foods means they drive compulsive consumption and hinder appetite regulation.
- The researchers propose that UPFs should be subject to controls comparable to those for cigarettes.
At present, there is no single universal description of UPFs. Some people describe them as products that contain ingredients you would not find in a home kitchen, such as stabilizers and additives.
Numerous experts rely on the NOVA food categorization to classify UPFs. This describes products that contain “combinations of ingredients, primarily of exclusive industrial use, typically made by a set of factory processes and methods.”
One new paper featured in The Millbank Quarterly proposed that ultraprocessed foods could be just as habit-forming as cigarettes.
“I concur with this research, as UPFs are specifically engineered to be highly appealing to most individuals,” stated a weight loss specialist who was not involved in the study.
Research from last year estimates that more than 73% of the food supply in the United States are highly processed.
“Tobacco and ultraprocessed foods are not just natural products but carefully designed delivery systems created purposely to increase physical and mental reward and habitual overuse,” wrote the review’s authors.
Are UPFs Addictive?
This analysis integrated findings from addiction, historical health policy, and dietary science to highlight sensory and structural characteristics that enhance the reinforcing potential of both cigarettes and UPFs.
“Not everyone is ‘addicted’’ to these foods, but for a meaningful minority, they cause classic habit-forming behaviors: intense desires, inability to stop, and continued use even with harmful consequences,” commented a heart health nutrition expert.
“These products are deliberately engineered with refined carbs, extra oils, salt, and taste additives to optimize pleasure and repeat consumption, and the food sector uses aggressive marketing tactics, particularly aimed at young people,” she added.
The authors analyzed five key areas:
- rapid absorption
- hedonic engineering, or designing foods to be extremely pleasurable
- perfecting the amount
- widespread availability
- misleading changes, or “wellness branding”
It was observed that, similar to cigarettes, ultraprocessed foods are fine-tuned to deliver the right dose of sugar.
“Processed carbs stimulate dopamine release through the a key neural pathway, whereas lipids achieve this via intestinal lipid sensing,” the authors noted.
“… Ultraprocessed foods with significant amounts of refined carbohydrates and extra oils are among the most highly addictive substances in the contemporary food supply. It is key that this processed carb and fat combination is almost nonexistent in nature.”
The way these foods quickly deliver “pleasure-inducing” chemicals to the brain makes them likely habit-forming, in a comparable way to cigarettes.
The paper stated that while tobacco are designed to provide nicotine rapidly, ultraprocessed foods are engineered to be broken down and absorbed quickly, as they usually have minimal fiber. This makes it easier for the system to process fat and sugar faster.
The researchers also note that UPFs provide intentional intense tastes that dissipate rapidly and mouthfeels that melt in your mouth. This collectively works to trigger increased pleasure signals and encourages you to eat more.
‘Health Washing’ in Tobacco, Ultraprocessed Foods
According to the analysis, both the cigarette and processed food sectors have long used a strategy called “health washing.”
This is where goods are marketed and altered to create an illusion of less danger while preserving the essential addictive properties.
Health washing in the tobacco industry gained traction in the 1950s with the advent of filter tips on smokes.
They were sold as safety features that would trap tar and particles before they reached the lungs. In reality, filters offer minimal meaningful benefit.
Yet, people often adjusted by taking bigger puffs or smoking more frequently, which negated any decrease in harmful intake.
Food manufacturers has adopted a comparable strategy. It employs packaging claims such as “reduced fat” or “sugar-free” to market UPFs.
However, these foods still contain the very highly reinforcing ingredient combinations. The problem is that these reformulations present a superficial impression of health while the item’s habit-forming nature and health risks remain intact.
Should UPFs Be Regulated?
The researchers noted at the end of their paper that food and smoking products are fundamentally different.
Nevertheless, they cautioned that certain UPFs act like engineered products rather than actual food. They recommended that public health policy ought to acknowledge this reality.
“Cigarettes provides a cautionary tale, and tobacco control offers a model of hope,” the authors stated.
Because of regulations, cigarette use rates in the US have declined and have “altered public perception of tobacco and eroded confidence in the sector.”
“I believe increased education regarding the harmful effects of ultra-processed foods is crucial to lower public intake and improve population wellness. The strategies employed to curb cigarette use have been successful and could be a useful model for ultra-processed foods as well,” commented one expert.
“It is not my view ultraprocessed foods should be regulated precisely like cigarettes, but they certainly deserve more robust, smoking policy-based policies: marketing restrictions, clear packaging warnings, tighter rules on wellness assertions, and limits in educational institutions or hospitals,” noted another nutrition professional.
The authors reminded people that minimally processed and whole foods have supported human health for thousands of years.